Answers
How often are Medicare Advantage provider directories wrong?
In three rounds of reviews starting in 2016, CMS found errors at 45.1%, 52.2% and 48.7% of the Medicare Advantage directory locations it checked. In Texas in November 2026, the directories of two plans still showed the old value for 307 providers who had updated NPPES when we last read them, and 13 of the 14 rows we checked by hand confirmed it.
Last checked
The facts
- Round 1, February to August 2016, 54 Medicare Advantage organizations: 45.1% of the directory locations checked were inaccurate.
Source: CMS Online Provider Directory Review Report, Round 1, 13 Jan 2017, - Round 2, September 2016 to August 2017, 64 Medicare Advantage organizations: 52.2% of the directory locations checked had at least one inaccuracy.
Source: CMS Online Provider Directory Review Report, Round 2, updated 31 Jan 2018, - Round 3, November 2017 to July 2018, 52 Medicare Advantage organizations: 48.7% of the directory locations checked had at least one inaccuracy.
Source: CMS Online Provider Directory Review Report, Round 3, 28 Nov 2018, - In our own Texas check, 307 providers had an NPPES change from 21 July 2026 to 10 November 2026 that Plans B and C did not show when we last read their directories.
Source: Argoseer change check, Texas, read 15 Nov 2026; 14 rows checked by hand,
Related
A correction or a question this page does not answer goes to info@argoseer.com.