Your directory is already public. The grade is next.
Anyone can read it on your website, and CMS scheduled directory data for Medicare Plan Finder from 1 October 2026. By law you grade its accuracy yourself from 2028, and the scores go public from 2029. Your 2028 bid is due on 7 June 2027, and the final rule is not expected before it.
24 days left
198 days left
406 days left
862 days left
What we will report, plan by plan
| Finding | Plan A | Plan B | Plan C | Plan D | Plan E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Still listed after Medicare shows they left | Held | Held | Held | Held | Held |
| NPPES changes not shown when we last read | Held | 188 providers as of 15 Nov 2026 | 137 providers as of 15 Nov 2026 | Held | Held |
| Listings across Texas directories | Held | Held | Held | Held | Held |
Validated so far: Texas, Plans B and C, for changes not shown. Other plans and findings are held until each passes its own check.
Half of it is visible from outside. We check that half.
Weights from proposed rule CMS-4214-P; the final rule may change them.
What we check
- Providers Medicare, the board or the registry shows as having left, still listed
- Address against the practice's own website, NPPES and PECOS
- Phone against the practice site and other payers
- Specialty against NPPES taxonomy and the state board
- The first date each difference was seen
What we do not
- Network or contract status (40%), only you hold that
- Whether the provider takes new patients
- Accessibility and telehealth
- Whether anyone answers the phone
What enforcement has looked like
EmblemHealth agreed to pay $2.5M to the New York Attorney General over inaccurate provider directories.
Source: New York Attorney General, press release, 19 Feb 2026.
Illinois requires insurers to verify their provider directories at least every 90 days.
Source: Illinois Department of Insurance, Company Bulletin 2025-23, 31 Dec 2025 (215 ILCS 124/25(a)(3)).
of provider directory locations had at least one inaccuracy in CMS's third online directory review (Nov 2017 to Jul 2018).
Source: CMS Online Provider Directory Review Report, Round 3.
From the proposal to public scores
- 3 Feb 2026REAL Health Providers Act signed
- 1 Oct 2026Plan directory data due on Medicare Plan Finder
- 16 Oct 2026Proposed rule issued
- 15 Dec 2026Comments close (we filed on 7 Nov)
- 2027Final rule, no date yet
- 1 Jan 2028Duties and the accuracy score take effect, by law
- Apr 2029Scores due to CMS, as proposed; public from 2029, by law
The federal rules we follow
| Rule | What it does |
|---|---|
| CMS-6098-P (CRUSH) Proposed. Comments due 19 Jan 2027 | Every Medicare enrollment change would be reported within 30 days. Source: CMS fact sheet, 16 Nov 2026 · Our post |
| CMS-4214-P Proposed. Comments close 15 Dec 2026 | Medicare Advantage directories would be graded A to F, and a provider who has left removed within five business days. |
| CMS-1844-F Final. Published 9 Nov 2026 | A Medicare enrollment revocation dates back to the day the problem began, and the time to bill after one drops from 60 days to 15. Source: CMS fact sheet, CMS-1844-F |
| REAL Health Providers Act Law. Applies from the 2028 plan year | Medicare Advantage plans check each provider's directory details at least every 90 days and remove a provider who has left within five business days. |
What a pre-audit includes
- Built from your directory file or public endpoint
- Every differing listing with its evidence and date
- One state, delivered in two weeks
Verification evidence
Provider confirmations every 90 days and a dated archive of what your directory showed. We will price it once CMS says what counts as verification.